Handmade vs. Store-Bought Debate – Which Baby Gifts Are Better?

If you’ve ever stood in the baby section of a department store, holding a fluffy stuffed animal in one hand and a cute onesie in the other, wondering if they’d make a good baby shower gift—you're not alone. Choosing the right baby present can be a bit of a mission. And if you’ve got a crafty mate or you’re a bit creative yourself, you might’ve asked the question – Are handmade baby gifts better than store-bought ones?

Shop Premium Baby Gift Hampers only at Baby Gifts Australia!

The Charm of Handmade Baby Gifts

There’s something warm and joyful about handmade gifts. A knitted blanket, a crocheted toy, or a personalised name plaque, everyone of these have hours of love and care put into thems. Someone’s hands—maybe even yours—spent days making something special, just for that little bub.

1. They’re Personal

Handmade gifts often feel more personal. They can be customised with the baby’s name, birth date, or chosen colours that match the nursery. A handmade baby beanie made with love by Nan or a cross-stitched wall hanging from a family friend? That’s the sort of thing that becomes a keepsake, treasured for years.

2. Made with Love (and Often Better Quality)

People who make handmade baby items usually take pride in what they do. You’ll often find better craftsmanship and materials—especially when it comes to knitted or sewn gifts. They’re made with care, not mass-produced in a factory somewhere overseas.

3. One-of-a-Kind

There’s very little chance another baby will have the exact same handmade toy or blanket. That makes the gift feel a little more special—like it was made just for that little person.

4. Supporting Small Creators

When you buy handmade (from local markets or online platforms like Etsy), you’re often supporting a small Aussie business or an individual maker. It’s a good feeling knowing your money’s going to someone passionate about their craft, not just a giant chain.

But it’s not all sunshine and rainbows...

The Realities of Handmade Gifts

1. Not Always Practical

While handmade gifts are lovely, they’re not always the most practical. A handmade jumper might look adorable, but if it’s itchy or not machine washable, it might never get worn. Babies go through a lot of outfit changes (hello, spit-up!), so practicality often wins.

2. Quality Can Vary

Just because something’s handmade doesn’t mean it’s made well. Not every DIY gift is created equal, and some might fall apart in the wash or have loose threads that aren’t safe for babies. If you're giving handmade, make sure it’s safe and well-finished.

3. Takes Time

If you’re making the gift yourself, it’s going to take time and effort. And let’s be honest—not everyone has that. Plus, not all of us have the skills (or patience) to crochet a giraffe or sew a tiny pair of booties.

Store-Bought Baby Gifts – Quick, Easy, Reliable

There’s a reason store-bought gifts are so popular—they’re convenient, often affordable, and you know what you’re getting.

1. Time-Saving and Easy

Need a gift in a hurry? A quick trip to the shops or an online order, and you’ve got a cute outfit, a set of teething toys, or a fancy nappy bag wrapped and ready. No stress, no mess, no late-night crafting marathons.

2. Tried and Tested Brands

Store-bought items often come from brands that parents know and trust. If it’s Bonds zippys (an Aussie staple!) or a Fisher-Price rattle, these products have usually been tested for safety and baby-friendliness. There’s comfort in knowing the gift is likely to be useful.

3. Practical Gifts That Get Used

Sometimes, nappies, baby wipes, or a stack of singlets are the most appreciated gifts of all. They might not be flashy or sentimental, but new parents are usually grateful for anything that makes their lives a bit easier.

4. Exchangeable if Needed

One big plus with store-bought gifts? If the baby gets double-ups, or the item isn’t quite right, the parents can return or exchange it. That’s not so easy with handmade items.

So… Which One’s Better?

Honestly? There’s no clear winner. Both handmade and store-bought baby gifts have their place, and the “better” choice really depends on who you are, who the gift is for, and the occasion.

When Handmade Might Win –

• You’re close to the parents and want to give something personal and meaningful.
• You’ve got the time (and skills!) to create something special.
• You’re supporting a local maker or small business.
• It’s a keepsake or nursery decor item.

When Store-Bought Might Be Better –

• You need a gift quickly or are short on time.
• You don’t know the parents well and want to play it safe.
• You want to give something practical or from a trusted brand.
• You’re contributing to a group gift like a pram, baby monitor, or car seat.

Why Not Both?

Here’s a thought—why not combine the two? Pair a handmade bib with a pack of nappies. Tuck a crocheted toy into a store-bought baby hamper. It’s the best of both worlds – something practical, and something with heart.

At the end of the day, what matters most is the thought behind the gift. Whether it’s lovingly stitched or conveniently purchased, if it’s given with care and kindness, it’ll be appreciated.

So next time you're headed to a baby shower or visiting a new arrival, just ask yourself – Do I want to give something heartfelt, helpful, or a little bit of both? Either way, you can’t go too far wrong.